Negotiation Skills for Settling
Personal Injury Claims

See also: Peer Negotiation

Settling a personal injury claim often requires negotiation between the injured party and the at-fault party’s insurance company.

Strong negotiation skills can help injured parties maximize their settlement or award. This article provides an overview of negotiation strategies and skills that can prove useful when trying to settle a personal injury claim.

Doctor holding an xray of a foot.

Understanding Liability

The first step is determining liability – who is at fault for the injury. Approximately 39.5 million personal injury cases require medical treatment occur annually in the U.S., which equals about 126.3 cases per 1,000 people. In 2021, around 2.5 million people were injured in auto accidents. To prove liability, injured parties need substantial evidence like detailed police reports, extensive medical records from before and after the injury, and credible eyewitness statements from multiple sources. Understanding liability is crucial for negotiations, as the at-fault party typically wants to pay as little as possible. Thoroughly proving liability makes it harder for the other party to evade responsibility or minimize the extent of the injuries.

Calculating Damages

Calculating damages involves meticulously documenting all financial losses incurred by the injured party, including medical bills, lost income, property damage, and pain and suffering. One effective method for quantifying pain and suffering uses a multiplier approach, where tangible losses are multiplied by a carefully considered factor between 1.5 and 5, with more severe injuries warranting a higher multiplier. Extensive documentation provides solid justification for the requested damages during negotiations. Quantifying even minor losses meticulously makes it more difficult for the other party to dispute or underestimate the claimed financial impacts.

Considering Alternate Dispute Resolution

Rather than going through an expensive, lengthy and unpredictable court trial, alternate dispute resolution methods like arbitration and mediation can facilitate settling. A 2005 Bureau of Justice Statistics study found the plaintiff success rate for personal injury cases that went to verdict was only about 50%. Alternate dispute resolution can help avoid an unfavorable verdict and expedite reaching a settlement. The process can often be scheduled faster than court dates, provides more confidentiality than public trials, and gives the parties more control over the procedures and outcome.

Employing Negotiation Tactics

Certain tactics can be used to gain leverage during negotiations. Make the first offer, aiming reasonably higher than what would fully satisfy you, then let the other party make a counteroffer. Thoroughly provide evidence to completely justify your requested amount. Point out multiple strengths supporting your case and multiple weaknesses hurting the other side's case. Small, strategic concessions can build trust and goodwill over time. Refraining from accepting the first counteroffer shows you have patience and won't settle for less than what's fair and justified.



Exhibiting Negotiation Skills

Employing certain skills can optimize negotiations. Actively listen without interruptions to fully understand the other party's stance. Ask thoughtful, open-ended questions to learn their interests, limitations and priorities. Remain calm and professional at all times, even if negotiations get tense or adversarial. Use clear, precise communication to avoid any possible misunderstandings. Adapt your strategy if necessary but stay firm on your core interests and established bottom line. Portray steady confidence in your case's merits based on your documentation and evidence. Leverage your extensive knowledge, ample evidence and thorough preparation.

Considering Settlement Context

Settlement context also matters. In product liability cases with flawed, dangerous products, the median payout was $748,000 according to a 2022 study. More severe, disabling injuries warrant much higher settlements, while minor injuries bring smaller settlements. If negotiations reach an impasse, showing willingness to go to court and start litigation may bring the other party back to the table with a better offer. Hiring an experienced Orlando personal injury lawyer like James D. Payer to fully represent you also greatly strengthens your position and negotiating leverage. Understanding settlement statistics and context helps set realistic expectations when beginning negotiations in your personal injury claim.

Additional Negotiation Strategies

Some other strategies can also help in negotiations. Have your attorney draft a formal demand letter detailing the injuries, liability facts, and specific settlement demand. This shows you are serious and makes the other party evaluate the risks of going to court. If they have made no offers, propose a high-low agreement defining a minimum and maximum settlement range to provide clarity. Make exchanges of information and documents early to avoid surprises later. Ask for a mediator if talks stall. Letting the other side know you have researched jury awards for similar cases can get their attention.

Preparing Your Evidence and Witnesses

Strong preparation is key to successful negotiations. Gather police reports, medical records, bills, tax returns, pay stubs, repair estimates, and other documentation as evidence of losses. Have doctors explain injuries and treatment in writing. Interview witnesses thoroughly and get their accounts in affidavits. Organize records chronologically and by category. Anticipate questions and prepare reasoned responses. Providing organized, compelling evidence demonstrates the validity of your demands.

Understanding Negotiation Psychology

Knowing negotiation psychology can also be advantageous. People tend to value their own contributions higher than concessions. Framing your offers as compromises or concessions can make them seem more fair. Make multiple smaller concessions rather than huge ones. Get the other party to publicly commit to an idea, then they will feel compelled to act consistently with it. People dislike losses more than they value equivalent gains. Emphasize what they stand to lose by going to court. Leveraging proven psychology principles can subtly influence negotiations.

Adjusting Your Approach

No single approach works for every negotiation. You may need to adapt your strategy based on factors like the strength of evidence, injuries, insurance company, adjuster, policy limits, witness credibility, jurisdiction’s claim trends, and economic conditions. Understand what motivates the other party and emphasize concessions that address their key interests. Remain flexible but focused on your goal. Integrating these considerations into your negotiating plan can help tailor your approach.

With diligent preparation, intimate knowledge of negotiation psychology and tactics, adaptable strategies and clear communication, injured parties can optimize outcomes. A strategic, informed approach to settling injury claims allows faster resolution while maximizing compensation for damages suffered. Despite each case's uniqueness, the principles and skills outlined here offer a roadmap for effective negotiation and the best chance for a favorable settlement.


About the Author


Boris Dzhingarov is a passionate blogger. He is the founder of Dzhingarov.com.

TOP